Mock Draft: Dolphins are on the clock, who should they take?

The Miami Dolphins have left themselves quite a lot of work to do in the NFL Draft next month.  Free agency is winding down and the Dolphins still have needs on the right side of the offensive line, at defensive end (pass rusher), at wide receiver (2?), at safety, and yes, at quarterback.  The Dolphins can still fill a hole or two by signing a veteran (Jake Scott, Phillip Wheeler, others).  They could also hold out hope that a veteran or two, an acorn if you will, could become available later this offseason as teams trim their rosters.  We’ll know sooner or later.

For today, though, we want to focus on the draft.  The Dolphins have a top 10 pick for the first time since they had # 1 overall in 2008, when they drafted Jake Long.  Like most years, everyone has an opinion on what the Dolphins should do with the #8 selection.  Should they take Ryan Tannehill, who some believe can be a franchise QB?  Should they take a supposed ‘elite’ pass rusher, like Quinton Coples?  Or should they invest another draft pick in the offensive line by drafting a Cordy Glenn or David DeCastro?  That last question probably made you throw your phone or computer onto the floor.

We’re curious to know what the majority of Dolphins fans would do with the #8 pick, if they were the Dolphins GM.  If I were GM, as I’ve mentioned before, I would try to trade down into the mid teens or around pick 20.  This would bring in another 2nd round pick (possibly more) and I would draft Brandon Weeden.  However, let’s take out the possibility of trading down, so a player must be selected. As the Dolphins GM, you have the following options on the board (among others) to choose from:

Ryan Tannehill, QB Texas A&M – Tannehill is coming of an impressive pro day…but really, pro days are meant to make the players participating look good…especially QBs.  The Dolphins offensive coordinator, Mike Sherman, knows Tannehill better than anyone since he coached him at Texas A&M.  Tannehill is a converted wide receiver with 19 career college starts. He has a good arm (not great), good accuracy and excellent athleticism.  According to many experts, he has all of the tools to become a franchise QB, but he’ll need 1-2 years to develop.

Quinton Coples, DE North Carolina – Coples has all of the measurables you look for in a defensive end.  He’s got long arms, he’s quick off the ball, and he’s good against the run and in pass rushing situations.  The question with Coples is his motor.  Last year he had a tendency to take plays off or not go at 100%.  However, the potential is there and if the Dolphins can tap into it, he could be another Jason Pierre Paul (who the Dolphins should’ve drafted a few years ago!)

Michael Floyd, WR Notre Dame – After trading Brandon Marshall for 2 third round picks, the Dolphins have a glaring hole ta wide receiver.  Joe Philbin has made it clear that he believes in a balanced offense with the QB spreading the ball around.  I expect the Dolphins to select two wide receivers in the draft.  The only question is where they will be taken.  This may seem high for Floyd, but the potential to be a very good WR is there.  Floyd is 6’3″, 220 lbs.  Floyd catches the ball with his hands instead of with his body, which is a good thing.  He uses his strength and size, not necessarily quickness to get separation from the cornerback.  He runs good routes and can get in and out of them quickly.  He ran a 4.47 40 yard dash at the combine, so he won’t blow by corners, but he has the size to make up for what he lacks in speed.

David DeCastro, OG Stanford – DeCastro is easily the best guard prospect in the draft.  Teaming him with Jake Long and Mike Pouncey would make for a very good offensive line, perhaps the best in the NFL.  #8 may seem high to take a guard, but that offensive line would give whoever the QB is, plenty of time to make his reads and go through his progressions.

Melvin Ingram, DE/OLB South Carolina – Ingram has a great motor and a knack for making the big plays, something the Dolphins have lacked.  The only knock on Ingram are his arms…they’re short.  This could pose problems against large offensive tackles.  However, Ingram’s stock has been on the rise and is said to have had an exceptional pro day.

There you go, that’s who’s left on the board.  Below is how the Draft is shaking out, and the Commissioner just announced that the Miami Dolphins are on the clock…..

1. Indianapolis Colts – Andrew Luck, QB Stanford

2. Washington Redskins - Robert Griffin III, QB Baylor

3. Minnesota Vikings – Matt Kalil, OT USC

4. Cleveland Browns – Trent Richardson, RB Alabama

5. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – Morris Claiborne, CB LSU

6. St. Louis Rams – Justin Blackmon, WR Oklahoma State

7. Jacksonville Jaguars – Riley Reiff, OT Iowa

Please leave a comment below to justify the pick you made in our poll above.  We’ve interested to know what pick you made and why you made it.  Thanks in advance for your participation!!

For the latest Miami Dolphins news from PhinNation.com, you can follow us on Twitter and Facebook

  • GADOLFAN

    I just selected Tannehill in the vote above but I believe if Trent Richardson is there get him, I know he doesn’t fill an immediate need but Bush is a FA next year and I know we will be in the Barkley sweepstakes next year too, if Richardson is gone then Tannehills the next best prospect, we don’t need a 1st round OL to put on the right side, LT maybe. Athletes like Coples come and go all the time, but their motavational issues keep them from being great.

    • Gaiter

      Tannehill? Let’s get real… He is by no means our franchise QB. Skip on a QB this year unless you pick Weeden up in the 2nd round. If Blackmon is there, you take him. Other than that it’s Ingram or Couples. Tannehill is another disastourous pick for Miami.

  • rodney wendling

    I chose Ryan Tannehill, the dolphins desperately need a quarterback who is going to make the players around him better and I believe that he has all the antangibles to be a successful quarterback in the nfl. I have watch a lot of game film on him and he is quite unique. I think he has the chance to be better than andrew luck, with the right situation and the right coaching.

  • sam

    Trade Ireland for a janitor. FIRE IRELAND NOW.COM

  • FELIX

    RYAN TANNEHILL-TO MANY VARIABLES, NOT BETTER THAN WHAT WE HAVE RIGHT NOW, AND NOT AN ANSWER FOR REBUILDING THE TEAM PURPOSE. MICHAEL FLOYD IS A NEED THIS SEAZON AND FOR YEARS TO COME.

  • http://Ed Eddie

    David De Castro. It’s like the column says “Teaming him with Jake Long and Mike Pouncey would make for a very good offensive line, perhaps the best in the NFL.” We already have a QB gents. His name is Matt moore. 6-3 last season. Give him a chance with a better protection and you will see the light at the end of the tunnel. Go Fins.

    • thorny

      Actually Matt Moore went 6 and 6

  • iam305jules

    I’d like to go after either Richardson or Blackmon, but it appears as they will be gone by the time we get to # 8, so, with the given scenario, my vote went to Tannenhill. If we should be so lucky as to get Blackmon, then I’d get Weeden in the 2nd round, yes, I know he is 28, but as he puts it, he hasn’t been sacked a whole lot and his body is relatively abuse free, so he maybe 28 but feels like a good 25… I’d just like to see the magic between Weeden and Blockmon at the NFL level…. some questions remain as to the type offence Weeden ran in college with the spread and all, but I’ll trust Philbin’s staff to bring them alone… Should Richardson be available at #8 (fat chance) then forget what I just wrote and get him.

    • iam305jules

      OK, I’d like to take my voe for Tannehill back and go for DeCastro… Get Weeden in the 2nd or Osweiller in the 3rd and give me K. Osamele and / or B. Wash insteadington in the 3rd if we were to get Weeden in the 3nd and get TY Hilton in the 4th… Not crazy about trading either up or down on this one. This is for sure, my last vote and it shall remain unchanged until the draft,,, unless I change my mind again.

  • CA_DolFan

    If I were the GM of the Dolphins, I would trade down and acquire more picks to fill some of the holes that we currently have. But for the sake of having to make a pick, I would select Tannehill. Too much upside, If we are above .500 this year we will not be in the Matt Barkley (USC) sweepstakes unless for some miracle reason he drops in the draft next year. Living in CA and a Trojan fan, he does have the goods to become a good NFL QB, just sucks that he decided to go back for his Senior Year (good for Trojan fans).

    With the 8th pick in the 2012 NFL draft the Dolphins select…. Ryan Tannehill, QB, Texas A&M

  • phinfan4sure

    If i was GM, I honestly have tobsay I would trade down and try to get another 2nd round pick. I agree with Bill, draft Weeden and work with what we have left. The better QB will prevail in training camp. But for the sake of the argument imI would draft Coples to compliment Cameron Wake. I agree whole heartedly that the Dolphins should have got Jason Pierre-Paul but we didn’t. Coples can be a stud in this league and I’m sure with him playing for pay will be all the motivation he needs to be a factor on our D-line. Stick with Matt Moore and grab a OG and a WR in the 2nd and 3rd. If things dont work out then we’re in the Barkley sweepstakes. But Moore deserves a shot.

    Fins up!

  • Tony

    I think we should trade up ahead of the Rams and take Blackmon and try to get Weeden in Round 2.

  • http://drdave Dave Burnette

    The NY Giants have showed how to beat Brady & the Pats ,with defense you must go DL or OLB at #8 ,then QB in the later rounds with Receivers in the 3rd.Its not rocket science put the pressure on Brady ,Sanchez, & Friz and you win the Division.

  • logan

    Drafting tTannehill is just setting us up for another dissapointment at QB people…